Friday, December 2, 2016

my feeling about Child abuse compo

Lets imagine i crashed into your car had no insurance nor did you so i gave you a letter of apology and $10 towards your repair would you be happy well thats how i feel about being offered a tiny payout for 40 years of abuse it would have been acceptable at the time but as the govt have dragged it out for years and cost us as unable to work because refused rehab so have suffered more because of it its also affected our relationships and our children so yes to be honest it is about the money as how dose less then 1,000 a year compensate for the abuse not just by our abusers but by the govt drawing it out for year after year fighting us at every turn and unjust amounts some got 100,000 and where well enough to work all their life and coped mentally others like me had to pay lawyers 36,000 to get 35,000 how is that right and i have not coped mentally been in and out of work because of it so the system is broken unjust and unfair i know others who paid 10,000 to a lawyer to get 10,000 for terrible abuses so it has to be about the money so we have enough to rebuild our life and pay for the rehab we need to be able to finally have a almost normal life or whats left of it as many many studies have proven people abused and made mentally ill have a 10 to 15 year shortened life span also adds to the abuse
a state apology  is grate but it dose not fix the damage they did just like the $10 towards fixing your car did little for you and if i was not mentally damaged by the trauma of the brain damage done by the ECT who knows i might have been the PM earning a nice living instead of living most of life hand to mouth on a benefit. now if all this was felt with very early on things would be much different its hard when we have been told what happened to us was wrong but the people who abused us where never told what they did was wrong nor did they get punished for their crime even when you swear an affidavit with 30 others all saying the same thing and police don't even have the decency to interview you abused again so no its not about millions but its about whats right and fair and just for not just the short time we where kids and abused but for the many years since we have had to suffer and fight to be heard and be ridiculed and called liars   


so do you understand if so good if no go to your kitchen take your best plate out of the cupboard throw it on the ground now say sorry to it, was it fixed? did it get back together somehow no you need to buy some glue and rehab it but it will never ever be the same plate  

Friday, November 25, 2016

Child abuse report 'shut down by '@chrisfinlaysonMP because the abuse was so shocking it would harm the @NZNational party

A former Human Rights Commissioner is accusing the government of killing off a critical report on the way it handled hundreds of cases of children abused in state care.
The report was written when Ros Noonan was Chief Human Rights Commissioner in 2011.

Chief Human Rights Commissioner David Rutherford said he and a team of lawyers found the report's conclusions were legally flawed. Photo: 123RF
It was never published because, she says, the Attorney General Chris Finlayson did not like its recommendations.
Many children in state care between the 1950s and 1980s suffered abuse and neglect that scarred them for life.
In 2009 the UN Committee Against Torture raised concerns about how New Zealand handled historic abuse claims. In 2011 the Human Rights Commission launched a review.
Ms Noonan said the draft report recommended an independent inquiry be set up. She did not think the Ministry for Social Development was impartial enough to handle victim's complaints.
Attorney General Chris Finlayson replied in a letter that he disagreed and the ministry was fair and impartial.
Ms Noonan believed Mr Finlayson was motivated by fears an independent inquiry would expose the government to liability.
"My clear impression is that he was trying to shut down the inquiry and the report. I think, clearly, he was concerned there would be a public interest in there being an independent inquiry and the government didn't want that."
Ms Noonan, who is the director of the Human Rights Centre at Auckland University Law School, was angered by Mr Finlayson's response - and that the report was not published.
"It's infuriating and sort of puzzling. I can't see, other than the cost of compensation, how New Zealand wouldn't be better off if we knew what had happened, we were able as a society to apologise to those our system damaged and we could make sure we didn't make the same mistakes in the future."
Noonan's successor, chief Human Rights Commissioner David Rutherford, said he and a team of lawyers found the report's conclusions were legally flawed. That was why it was not published.
He said the UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment) did not require an independent inquiry in such cases, only that the process was impartial.
The real issue to focus on was if the MSD process was impartial enough, he said.
Victims do not trust government - judge
She wanted an independent body that holds MSD accountable and can investigate historic claims.
Mr Rutherford did not disagree.
"I would listen to Carolyn Henwood's view any day of the week over anyone else who's dealt with this stuff. We are definitely of the view, and it's different from this MSD claims process, that New Zealanders need to understand what happened here."
Judge Henwood's panel, which the government intended as a temporary measure, was disestablished in 2015.
The Ministry had set up an historic abuse claims unit before CLAS started.
Judge Henwood said many victims did not trust it.
"The department is the perpetrator and also the person trying to put it right. Some people are very, very anti the department because of all the harm and the way they've been dealt with over the years. So I don't think it's satisfactory and it's still not satisfactory. I think something independent is needed."
Attorney General Chris Finlayson declined to be interviewed, but a spokesperson said in a written statement:
"In 2011 the Chief Human Rights Commissioner invited the Attorney-General, along with a range of other parties, to consult over the Commission's report on the State's response to historic claims of abuse.

"The Attorney-General raised a number of concerns he had about the quality and objectivity of the report for their consideration."


Aaron Smale Te Manu Korihi Reporter aaron.smale@radionz.co.nz




Thursday, November 10, 2016

why i am so angry with NZ Government

well just imagine that you yourself as a young 15-year-old boy were raped and tortured and went to the police and told them only to have the police tell you that you are just another mentally defective  trouble maker and refuse to investigate in fact threaten to arrest you so you take off and the anger builds so you keep fighting and years later have another go only with 30 other people swearing on oath the same thing happened to them so police spend years investigating < delaying > only to come back and say without even interviewing us sorry we can't find enough evidence to press charges. then 10 years later apologize for missing some evidence that would be good enough to bring him to trial only the government won't extradite Dr. Selwyn Leeks from Australia to stand trial as it would embarrass them as he was a state employee abusing wards of the state children.
so we go to the UN who ruled we should get access to full rehab and proper compensation only the NZ govt won't have a bar of it and say they have done enough for the survivors ha they have done nothing for me the lying pricks so now can you understand my anger.
well as you should be angry too due to the millions that have been spent on lawyers over the last 40 years trying to stop us from getting justice so if you think you can get justice in NZ think again but I will never give up and will keep attacking what ever party is in power with the facts until my dying day

visit https://www.facebook.com/groups/190198281412498/
 UN Committee against Torture finds NZ in Violation of Abuse Claimants Human Rights



Boy 'Tortured' just like NZ Govt treated its child... http://kiwijustice2.blogspot.com/2016/07/boy-tortured-just-like-nz-govt-treated.html?spref=tw 

Thursday, October 13, 2016

Psychiatrist Faces Trial over Claim Electroshock Therapy Damaged Cardiologist’s Brain

Posted by Arlin Crisco on Oct 11, 2016 11:36:39 PM


West Palm Beach, FL—Trial is scheduled to begin this week against a South Florida psychiatrist accused of negligence in overseeing electroshock treatments that allegedly left a cardiologist with brain damage. Dadi v. Sharma, 2011CA16027.
According to court documents, cardiologist Dr. Shaul Dadi claims psychiatrist Dr. Praturi Sharma oversaw electroshock therapy, otherwise known as electroconvulsive therapy or ECT, on Dadi in 2010 without obtaining the his informed consent. Dadi contends the ECT, intended to treat his depression following the breakup of his medical practice, was delivered in voltage bursts far beyond typical standards under the circumstances.
HubSpot Call-to-Action Code

end HubSpot Call-to-Action Code
Dadi claims the treatments have left him with brain damage and severe memory loss, according to his complaint in the case.
In response, Sharma contends he properly obtained informed consent, followed appropriate treatment standards, and claims Dadi’s own negligence was the cause of any long-term injury following ECT, according to court documents.
During an ECT procedure, electric currents are passed through a patient’s brain, triggering a brief seizure. According to the Mayo Clinic website, physicians believe ECT can change a patient’s brain chemistry, reversing some types of depression and other mental health issues.
Trial in the case is expected to last at least a week. CVN will provide live gavel-to-gavel coverage of the trial.
Email Arlin Crisco at acrisco@cvn.com
Related Information
Dr. Shaul Dadi is represented by Jeffery Fenster, of Fenster & Cohen P.A. and Nancy La Vista of Clark, Fountain, La Vista, Prather, Keen & Littky-Rubin.
Dr. Praturi Sharma is represented by Cole, Scott & Kissane’s Michael Brand and Jami Gursky.
Not a subscriber?

Tuesday, September 27, 2016

links to sites on nz mental health abuse in NZ




2004-0626 - NZ Herald - Cold case parents' agony
by Stephen Cook - The death certificate said James Kake died of a severe asthma attack, but his family were never convinced. Now they are joining the growing chorus of calls seeking a public inquiry into claims of serious abuse at mental hospitals.


2004-0623 - The Press - Desperate days at Sunnyside recalled
By Kamala Hayman - Sally (not her real name) knew she was not like other girls. Withdrawn and depressed, she was secretly scrubbing her stomach with sandpaper. Sometimes she would grab a piece of broken glass, a razor blade – anything sharp – and slice into her arms and legs. She had started self-harming when she was 12 years old……………


2004-0623 - The Press - Abuse victims call for Govt inquiry
By Kamala Hayman - A woman subjected to years of shock treatment and threatened with a lobotomy while a teenage patient at Christchurch's Sunnyside Hospital in the 1960s is seeking an inquiry. The woman, now aged 56, is joining more than 200 former child psychiatric patients nationwide taking legal action against the Government over alleged mistreatment during the 1960s and 1970s.


2004-0623 - NZ Parliament - Questions for Oral Answer
Psychiatric Institutions—Abuse -  Ron Mark (NZ First) to the Attorney-General: Will she be ordering an inquiry into claims of serious abuse at psychiatric institutions during the 1960s and 1970s; if not, why not?


2004-0621 - NZ Herald - Abuse complaints 'should be believed'
by Martin Johnston - The more than 200 former psychiatric patients claiming compensation for mistreatment should be believed because of the sheer force of their numbers, a lawyer says. Sonja Cooper, who represents more than half the claimants, said their credibility was established by so many people recounting similar experiences.


2004-0620 - Newstalk ZB - Abuse inquiries flow in
There has been a steady stream of inquiries from former employees and patients over abuse allegations at psychiatric hospitals. Almost 200 official complaints have been made by people who allege they were physically and sexually abused in state mental health hospitals in the 1960s and 1970s.


2004-0619 - The Press - Nelson abuse claims
Four former patients of Ngawhatu Psychiatric Hospital in Nelson have lodged formal complaints of abuse at the institution, including allegations of experimentation on patients. Almost 200 complaints have been made by people who allege they were abused in mental health hospitals around New Zealand during the 1960s and 1970s.


2004-0619 - NZ Herald - Witness to boy's death believes there was a cover-up
by Stephen Cook - A chill cuts through the air as Stephen Lindsay slumps on to his sofa bed. As he pores over pages of crumpled documents trying to piece together his thoughts, his eyes suddenly bulge and dart to the other side of his cramped and cluttered haunt. Then his composure melts. ……..


2004-0619 - NZ Herald - Mother wants to know how son died at psychiatric hospital
by Martin Johnston - Clement Matthews' mother wants the police to get to the truth about his death in Kingseat mental hospital 36 years ago. Rebecca Matthews, 63, said yesterday that she first learned of the police re-opening their investigation into the 1968 death of 11-year-old Clement in last week's Weekend Herald.


2004-0618 - NZ Herald - More allegations of abuse at mental institution
NZPA - Four former patients of Ngawhatu Psychiatric Hospital in Nelson have lodged formal complaints of abuse at the institution, including allegations of experimentation on patients. Almost 200 complaints have been made by people who allege they were abused in mental health hospitals around New Zealand during the 1960s and 1970s. Wellington lawyer Roger Chapman said today a "steady number" of former patients of Ngawhatu Hospital were now coming forward.


2004-0618 - Nelson Mail - Abuse complaints mount against psychiatric hospital
by Sheriee Smith - Four more former patients of Ngawhatu psychiatric hospital have lodged formal complaints of alleged abuse at the institution - including claims of experimentation on patients. Almost 200 complaints have been made by people who allege they were abused in mental health hospitals around New Zealand during the 1960s and 1970s.


2004-0615 - NZ Herald - PM ponders response to psychiatric abuse allegations
by Audrey Young - The Prime Minister yesterday raised the possibility that complaints about abuse in mental hospital could be dealt with through mediation. However, she said the Government needed more information before it decided between that approach or an inquiry.


2004-0614 - NZ Herald - More patients say they were abused in asylums
by Martin Johnston - More former patients have come forward alleging that they were abused in mental asylums during the 1960s and 1970s. The Weekend Herald revealed that the claims of widespread mistreatment that were previously confined to the former Porirua and Lake Alice asylums encompass most of the closed mental hospitals from Auckland to Otago.


2004-0614 - Nelson Mail - Nelson patients alleging abuse
The Government is considering an inquiry into claims of serious abuse at mental health hospitals, Prime Minister Helen Clark said today. Almost 200 complaints have been made by former patients who allege they were abused in mental asylums during the 1960s and 1970s.


2004-0612 - One News - Police reopen 1960s Kingseat case
The death of an 11-year-old boy nearly four decades ago at an Auckland psychiatric hospital is being investigated again by police. The case has been reopened after a witness spoke out against the original coroner's findings. The case is also adding weight to calls for a commission of inquiry into claims of abuse at psychiatric institutions in the 1960s and '70s.


2004-0612 - NZ Herald - Woman recalls Tokanui trauma
by Martin Johnston - Mary was put in Tokanui mental hospital in 1968 to help her to recover from depression. Aged 18, she was depressed after the birth of a baby, the second of her four children. But instead of receiving help, Mary says, she suffered beatings and sexual abuse, and was left damaged by electro-convulsive therapy (ECT).


2004-0612 - NZ Herald - Police re-open boy's hospital death case after 36 years
by Martin Johnston - The police have re-opened the 36-year-old case of a boy's death at Kingseat psychiatric hospital south of Auckland, after a witness said a nurse beat the youngster. A 1968 coroner's finding that 11-year-old Clement Matthews died of pneumonia has been challenged by former patient Stephen Lindsay, who was 14 at the time. He says he saw a male nurse attack Clement 12 hours before he was found dying in his locked room.


2004-0612 - Newstalk ZB - 200-plus abuse claims from ex-psych patients
Lawyers are expecting a landslide of abuse claims from former psychiatric patients. More than 200 claims, alleging physical abuse in state-run institutions, are believed to be in the pipeline. Police have reopened the 36-year-old case of Clement Matthews, who was ruled to have died of pneumonia at Kingseat psychiatric hospital, south of Auckland.


2004-0602 - Dominion Post - Porirua abuse claims rise to 130
The number of claims against the Crown for alleged physical, sexual and mental abuse at Porirua Hospital during the 1960s and 70s had risen to about 130 by yesterday. One of the lawyers spearheading the legal action, Sonja Cooper, said more claims were expected. "People find it difficult to talk about this kind of abuse and for some it can take months or even years to summon up the courage."


2004-0601 - Dominion Post - Patient abuse claims investigated
Complaints of mistreatment of former patients at Porirua Hospital are under investigation by the Crown Law Office, it has been revealed. Prime Minister Helen Clark and Attorney-General Margaret Wilson have left the door open to an inquiry but say the complaints must be investigated first. Ms Wilson confirmed yesterday that the Crown was investigating 62 claims about treatment at various psychiatric institutions, including Porirua, and a further 44 complaints were likely to be filed.


2004-0531 - One News - Crown probes alleged patient abuse
The Attorney General says the Crown is currently investigating 62 allegations of past abuse of patients at psychiatric hospitals. Margaret Wilson issued a statement on Monday afternoon in response to claims by former patients on the Sunday programme that they were physically abused by staff at Porirua Hospital in the 1960s and 1970s.


2004-0531 - NZ Government - Post Cabinet Press Conference
Rt. Hon Helen Clark -  Media: Is the government considering any sort of inquiry into the allegations of abuse at Porirua?    PM: That has been referred to Crown Law and the Attorney-General. We’re investigating 62 claims, which have been filed, and I understand Margaret Wilson will have a statement out later today.


2004-0323 - Manawatu Standard - Lake Alice decision delay upsets victims
A preliminary decision about laying charges against former Lake Alice Hospital staff who allegedly abused and tortured children in the 1970s is expected next month. The Crown Law Office is expected to give the Police Commissioner's Office its advice within weeks. Then Commissioner Robert Robinson will decide whether to lay charges.


2004-0306 - Manawatu Standard - Raped and tortured: A New Zealand childhood
The demons of Lake Alice still haunt the people who lost their childhoods there. Lee Matthews talks to a survivor. "We were doomed people in Lake Alice because nobody helped us. We soon learned not to complain. We knew nobody would listen."

The Government is cynically banking on former pyschiatric patients giving up and going away by making justice too difficult to attain, say former Lake Alice Hospital residents in Palmerston North.

by Kamala Hayman - A former Christchurch psychiatric patient, subjected to years of shock treatment and threatened with a lobotomy, has dismissed as a "waste of time" Government plans to hear abuse claims in a confidential forum ……………… But a former Sunnyside patient, still living in Christchurch, could not see the point of the forum nor of further counselling.


NZPA - Former psychiatric hospital patients claiming compensation for abusive treatment are angered by Government plans to set up a confidential forum instead of an inquiry, their lawyers say. Attorney-General Margaret Wilson yesterday said former psychiatric patients who claimed to have suffered abuse while in hospital would be able to talk about their experiences at a confidential forum.


The Government has rejected calls to set up an inquiry into the allegations by hundreds of former patients that they were abused in psychiatric hospitals. Instead, it is creating a special forum to hear the stories of former patients, their families and hospital staff - forcing people who want compensation to go through the courts. Attorney-General Margaret Wilson said the forum, chaired by ombudsman and former judge Anand Satyanand, would refer people where necessary to the appropriate agencies, such as ACC, the Health and Disability Commissioner or the police. It could also refer people for state-paid counselling. 


by Fran Tyler - Former psychiatric patients who say they were abused by hospital staff are angry at the Government's refusal to hold a public inquiry. Attorney-General Margaret Wilson yesterday announced plans to instead establish a non-public forum to allow former patients, their families and hospital staff an avenue to air their complaints and stories. 


Former psychiatric patients who claim they have suffered abuse will be given an opportunity to tell their stories at a confidential forum. The government is setting up the forum so former patients, their families and former staff can gain acknowledgement of their experiences. Attorney-General Margaret Wilson says they looked carefully at holding an inquiry, but many former psychiatric patients wanted a way to talk about their stories. 


A group representing former mental health service users is outraged that the government is setting up a confidential forum to hear their claims of abuse. About 300 former patients have made complaints about their treatment at mental hospitals across New Zealand when most were aged between eight and 16. They have alleged beatings and sexual abuse by staff and other patients, excessive use of electro-shock treatment and drugs and solitary confinement.


Press Release by Margaret Wilson - The government will establish a forum for former psychiatric patients who claim to have suffered abuse while in hospital, Attorney-General Margaret Wilson announced today. The Confidential Forum for Former In-Patients of Psychiatric Hospitals will invite former patients, their families and hospital staff members to tell the stories of their experiences in psychiatric institutions. "The forum is designed to give former patients a chance to talk about their experiences in a non-critical and confidential environment," Margaret Wilson said.


A new forum is being set up for former psychiatric patients who claim to have been abused while in institutions. Former patients, their families and hospital staff will be able to talk openly of their experiences. Attorney-General Margaret Wilson says it will be a confidential and non-critical forum, chaired by an Ombudsman and administered by the Internal Affairs Department and Health Ministry. 


The Attorney-General says compensation issues must be kept separate from a new forum for psychiatric patients who claim they were abused. The Confidential Forum for Former In-Patients of Psychiatric Hospitals, run by the Health Ministry and Internal Affairs, will provide a way for former psychiatric patients to formally register their claims. It will invite former patients, their families and hospital staff members to tell of their experiences. 


For Hake Halo, Lake Alice Hospital was a place of terror which overshadowed the rest of his life. Now just a collection of run-down rural buildings with cows munching grass outside, in the 1970s it was the place where the then teenaged Hake says he was punished with electric shocks and painful injections by nurses and doctors trying to alter youngsters' behaviour. 


An almost audible sigh can be heard from New Zealanders as they contemplate yet another labyrinthine case of institutional abuse and the liturgy of apologies and compensation that will inevitably go with it. After the St John of God, Porirua Mental Hospital, Nazareth House, Salvation Army and prison solitary confinement affairs, and others, we could do without the deep flesh wound that is beginning to suppurate at Waiouru



by Fran Tyler - Former psychiatric patients and social welfare children taking cases against the Crown over alleged abuse have accused the Government of discrimination. When news broke of allegations by army cadets that they suffered abuse between the 1950s and 1980s, Defence Minister Mark Burton immediately promised an independent investigation, one of the groups' lawyers, Sonja Cooper, said.


The number of claims alleging abuse and mistreatment at psychiatric hospitals during the 1960s and 1970s is continuing to climb. The Crown Law Office says there are now 77 individual claims from former patients, many of them relating to Porirua Hospital


by Amanda Warren - A group seeking redress for alleged abuse in psychiatric hospitals hopes huge public response will bolster its calls for Government action. Helen Gilbert, a spokeswoman for psychiatric survivor groups, said calls had been flowing in to groups around the country following the coalition's July call for a new method of compensation. 


Calls have been flowing into psych survivor groups around the country from people seeking redress over historic abuse received in New Zealand mental institutions. Spokesperson for the coalition of groups Helen Gilbert says that since the groups first called for the Government to set-up a redress process in July there has been a steady stream of phone calls to consumer groups around the country from vulnerable people wanting to tell their stories.


People continue to come forward alleging abuse and mistreatment by psychiatric hospital staff at Porirua and other hospitals. Wellington lawyer Roger Chapman, with lawyer Sonja Cooper, is spearheading action against the Crown on behalf of those claiming physical, emotional and sexual abuse at the hospitals in the 1960s and 1970s.


by Haydon Dewes - More people continue to come forward to allege abuse and mistreatment at the hands of psychiatric hospital staff at Porirua and other hospitals. More than 300 people had come forward and that number was climbing, said Wellington lawyer Roger Chapman, who with lawyer Sonja Cooper is spearheading action against the Crown on behalf of those claiming physical, emotional and sexual abuse at the hospitals in the 1960s and 70s.

The number of claims alleging abuse and mistreatment at psychiatric hospitals during the 1960s and 70s is continuing to climb, as more former patients come forward. The Crown Law Office says there are now 77 individual claims from former patients - many of them relating to Porirua Hospital.


NZPA - Attorney-General Margaret Wilson says she is exploring ways for former psychiatric patients to avoid court cases if they want to when they seek compensation for their abuse claims. The historic allegations surfaced earlier this year and cover claims of widespread mistreatment at most of New Zealand's mental hospitals in the 1960s and 1970s. Ms Wilson said yesterday that so far 68 individual claims had been filed in the High Court and she understood more than 300 people had not yet filed.


Attorney-General Margaret Wilson has indicated to former psychiatric patients with abuse claims that she is willing to consider negotiated settlements if they want to avoid going through the courts. The claims in question largely relate to those from former Porirua Hospital patients.


by Martin Johnston - The police are taking too long to investigate criminal complaints against psychiatrist Selwyn Leeks, say supporters of patients behind the claims. On Saturday, the Weekend Herald revealed that the Government had paid a further $4.2 million in compensation to former psychiatric patients at Lake Alice Hospital, in addition to the $6.5 million paid to 95 others in 2001.


Psychiatric survivor groups are banding together in their fight for compensation for the institutional torture and abuse they suffered at the hands of the state. Human rights advocate Helen Gilbert said thousands of people had experienced abuse and torture at the hands of the state, ranging from electric shock treatment, medication and seclusion as punishment to unnecessary long-term incarceration.


Former mental health patients are calling for the Government to set up a national process to deal with historic claims of abuse at psychiatric intitutions. The Psych Survivors Redress Coalition, which represents patient groups across the country, is making the call following recent reports of abuse of patients at Porirua hospital.


by Martin Johnston - The Government has paid a second wave of former psychiatric patients about $47,000 each, on average, in compensation for abuse they suffered at Lake Alice Hospital. The 88 who received the $4.2 million were patients of the hospital's notorious child and adolescent unit, run by psychiatrist Selwyn Leeks.


By Martin Johnston - Action to settle former mental hospital patients' compensation claims against the Crown for alleged abuse may be about to begin. Crown Law (the Government's lawyers) has arranged to meet lawyers acting for more than 200 former patients.

by Fran Tyler - Publicity over abuse at Porirua and other psychiatric hospitals has led to the number of claimants rising to more than 300 since legal action was first revealed two years ago. Wellington lawyer Sonja Cooper, one of those spearheading the joint action against the Crown, says of those at least 200 are claiming physical, emotional or sexual abuse at Porirua during the 1960s and 1970s. So far 65 claims have been filed in the High Court.


By Fran Tyler - Publicity over abuse at Porirua and other psychiatric hospitals has led to the number of claimants rising to more than 300 since legal action was first revealed by The Dominion Post two years ago. Wellington lawyer Sonja Cooper, one of those spearheading the joint action against the Crown, says that of those at least 200 are claiming physical, emotional or sexual abuse at Porirua during the 1960s and 70s.


by Phil Taylor - Brutal treatment of patients was the culture of the Porirua Mental Hospital in the 1960s, four former workers have said. The four women told the Weekend Herald that electric shock treatment was routinely used as punishment and patients were drugged into zombie-like states to make them more manageable. The women - students at the time - said part of their duties was to hold patients down while shock treatment was applied.


by Sheriee Smith - Complaints of serious mistreatment of patients at Ngawhatu Psychiatric Hospital are mounting. Since the Government announced last month it was looking at more than 200 complaints of abuse at psychiatric hospitals around New Zealand, nine former patients at Nelson's Ngawhatu Hospital have lodged claims with Wellington lawyer Roger Chapman.


2005-1107 - ODT - Perils of unproven allegations
by Lynley Hood - News that police have found no evidence of criminal offending by Dr Selwyn Leeks, former head of the adolescent unit at Lake Alice Hospital, has been greeted with dismay by the Citizens Commission on Human Rights. ……Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR), it should be noted, is a subsidiary of the virulently anti-psychiatry Church of Scientology. It has no connection with the Human Rights Commission, which is a government agency.


2005-1028 - NZ Lawyer - Reliable evidence and due process
by Lynley Hood - News that the police have found no evidence of criminal offending by psychiatrist Dr Selwyn Leeks, former head of the child and adolescent unit at Lake Alice Hospital, has been greeted with dismay by the psychiatric patient advocacy group, Citizen's Commission on Human Rights (CCHR)……………. The most significant recent development in almost 30 years of allegations of abuse at the Lake Alice child and adolescent unit is the 2001 report of retired High Court Judge Sir Rodney Gallen. After reviewing a clutch of allegations, Gallen advised government, "I am satisfied that in the main the allegations which have been made are true and reveal an appalling situation... The best summary I can make is that the children concerned lived in a state of extreme fear and hopelessness.


2005-0922 - Dominion Post - Inquiry finds no evidence of offending
by Kelly Andrew - A former Lake Alice patient is disgusted police have decided not to charge a psychiatrist accused of abusing young people there in the 1970s.  Police say they have found no evidence of criminal offending after investigating more than 20 complaints from former patients of Selwyn Leeks, who headed the child and adolescent unit of the now-closed hospital near Wanganui.


2005-0921 - NZ Herald - No proof of abuse by doctor, say police
by Martin Johnston - The police say they have no evidence of criminal offending by Dr Selwyn Leeks, the psychiatrist whom former patients accuse of abusing them with electric shock therapy in the 1970s…… A police national headquarters spokeswoman said yesterday: "there is no disclosed activity or intervention with patients at Lake Alice that amounts to criminal offending on the part of Dr Selwyn Leeks. On that basis there is neither requirement nor authority to seek the extradition of Dr Leeks from Australia."

2005-0803 - NZ Herald - New probe looks into Lake Alice
by Martin Johnston - An Australian medical authority has begun interviewing former Lake Alice Hospital patients, over their claims that they were mistreated under the regime of psychiatrist Dr Selwyn Leeks. The Medical Practitioners Board of Victoria is preparing for a formal hearing into the allegations against Dr Leeks, who headed the child and adolescent unit of the hospital near Wanganui.


2005-0707 - One News - Abuse claims in high court's hands
The fate of hundreds of historic compensation claims by former psychiatric patients who say they were abused while institutionalised is now in the hands of the high court. The former patients want the way cleared to sue the government for mistreatment dating back several decades at Porirua Hospital. A former patient, who wants to remain anonymous, claims that he was abused at the psychiatric hospital, where he was sent by his mother when he was just 14-years-old.

The Internal Affairs' Minister has made two new appointments to the forum for former psychiatric patients who claim to have suffered abuse while in hospital….The new forum members are former IHC chief executive and Mental Health Commission chairwoman Jan Dowland and mental health consumer advisor Anne Helm.



2006-1026 - NZ National Party - Hodgson dodgy on Lake Alice payout
by Jonathan Coleman - Continued delays in paying out compensation to Paul Zentfeld, a claimant in the Lake Alice compensation case, are completely unsatisfactory, says National's Associate Health spokesman (Mental Health), Dr Jonathan Coleman.

2006-1011 - NZ Herald - Ministry to appeal Lake Alice compensation ruling
The Ministry of Health is to appeal against a court ruling that it must increase compensation to a former Lake Alice psychiatric hospital patient by more than $34,000. The ministry said yesterday that there was an error of law in the Wellington District Court ruling on the case brought by Paul Zentveld that his compensation be restored to nearly $115,000.

2006-1006 - Stuff - Date set for former psychiatric patients' action against govt
NZPA - One of the lawyers representing around 350 former psychiatric patients seeking compensation from the Government says the first cases will go before the courts next year. The first two cases have been set down for October 2007. The former patients are alleging they suffered physical, sexual and mental abuse at mental institutions, while in state care. In 2001, the Government apologised and paid compensation to a group of former patients of the Lake Alice Hospital child and adolescent unit, near Marton, which closed in the late 1970s. It later extended this to a second group, bringing to $10.7 million the total paid to 183 people. The group of around 350 former patients who were cared for in other state-run institutions say they too should be paid compensation.

2006-0922 - National Business Review - PM's conduct questioned
by Deborah Hill Cone - A Wellington District Court judge has exposed a secret deal in which the government took a cut of millions of dollars from compensation payments to former mental hospital patients. In a bold judgment out this week Judge Tom Broadmore has criticised what he describes as the "political" decision made at the highest levels of government to secretly take 30% of the compensation payments from victims of mistreatment at government psychiatric institution, Lake Alice, to cover non-existent "legal fees."


2006-0922 - NZ National Party - Lake Alice deal: Hodgson must explain
Press release by Dr Jonathon Coleman - The Minister of Health needs to come clean and explain to the public exactly how the Government reached a decision to withhold money awarded to second-round claimants in the Lake Alice case, says National Party Associate Health spokesman responsible for mental health, Dr Jonathan Coleman.


2006-0915 - Dominion Post - Mistreated ex-patient given extra $35,000
A former Lake Alice patient, mistreated at the institution, has won a further payout of nearly $35,000 from the Health Ministry. Wellington District Court judge Tom Broadmore has ruled that Paul Zentveld should have been paid $114,912 in damages for his mistreatment at the psychiatric hospital between 1972 and 1978. Instead, he had received only $80,438


2006-0914 - Radio NZ - Lake Alice payout topped back up by court
A former Lake Alice patient has won a four year battle to have his compensation paid out in full. Paul Zentveld was awarded 115-thousand dollars in compensation for the way he was treated during his stay at the psychiatric hospital near Bulls


2006-0914 - NZ National Party - Health Ministry $3 million payout bungle
Press release by Dr Jonathon Coleman - National Party Associate Health spokesman Dr Jonathan Coleman says a Ministry of Health bungle could cost taxpayers more than $3 million in extra compensation payments.


2006-0913 - NZ Parliament - Questions And Answers
In resonse by Pete hodgson - ......The member need only look at today's media coverage regarding the horrors of Lake Alice Hospital to know that deinstitutionalisation not only costs more but improves people's lives.


2006-0913 - NZ Herald - Lake Alice patient's payout up $34,000
by Martin Johnston - A former patient of the notorious Lake Alice psychiatric hospital near Wanganui has won an increase of more than $34,000 in his payout. Aucklander Paul Zentveld, 45, has won the top-up in a ruling in which the judge criticises the Crown's position as "Kafkaesque".


2006-0829 - NZ Herald - Psychiatrist must pay $55,000 after sex abuse case
by Martin Johnston - Former New Zealand psychiatrist Dr Selwyn Leeks has been ordered to pay $55,000 in damages for sexually abusing a former patient. The payment was ordered by an Australian court which found that Dr Leeks "took advantage ... of a disturbed psychiatric patient"


2006-0828 - Waikato Times - Damages ruling heartening
The Citizens Commission on Human Rights, which encouraged former Lake Alice Hospital patients to complain to police about a psychiatrist they said abused them, is heartened by an Australian court decision against him.


2006-0828 - The Press - Damages awarded
An organisation encouraging former Lake Alice Hospital patients to complain to police about a psychiatrist who they say abused them is heartened by an Australian court decision against him.


2006-0828 - Manawatu Standard - Court rules against doctor
An organisation encouraging former Lake Alice Hospital patients to complain to police about a psychiatrist is heartened by an Australian court decision against him. The Melbourne County Court has awarded $55,000 to a woman who said Selwyn Leeks sexually abused her as a patient in 1979 and 1980.


2006-0828 - Dominion Post - Victory in sex abuse case gives lift to group
by Colin Patterson - An organisation encouraging former Lake Alice Hospital patients to complain to police about a psychiatrist they say abused them is heartened by an Australian court decision against him. The Melbourne County Court has awarded $55,000 in damages to a woman who complained Selwyn Leeks sexually abused her while she was his patient in 1979-1980.


2006-0727 - Newstalk ZB - Last forum for former patients
Former patients of psychiatric hospitals have until Monday to register for the last forum to be held in Hamilton in October. The confidential forum will give patients, their family and staff the chance to share their experiences at hospitals.



2006-0726 - Manawatu Standard - Lake Alice extradition bid 'too soon'
by Mervyn Dykes - Police say calls to extradite a former head of Lake Alice psychiatric hospital from Australia to face charges in New Zealand are premature. "It is far too early to talk about extradition," the officer heading the inquiry, Christchurch-based Detective Superintendent Malcolm Burgess, said yesterday. There have been calls from some former Lake Alice patients for psychiatrist Selwyn Leeks to be extradited to face charges of abusing patients at the hospital's adolescent unit, which closed in 1978.

2006-0725 - Manawatu Standard - Lake Alice patients urged to back extradition
by Mervyn Dykes - Former patients of Lake Alice psychiatric hospital who suffered abuse from staff in the 1970s are being urged to join an extradition call against a former head of the unit. "We are calling one final time for the children of Lake Alice to come forward," said the chief executive of the Citizen's Commission on Human Rights, Steve Green, last night.


2006-0721 - Manawatu Standard - Lake Alice doctor quits
The psychiatrist accused of mistreating young patients at Lake Alice Hospital in the 1970s has effectively handed in his medical licence in Australia, the New Zealand Herald reports today. Selwyn Leeks was today to face a disciplinary hearing, accused of unprofessional conduct, in Melbourne


2006-0721 - Stuff - Lake Alice psychiatrist hands in licence
NZPA - Dr Selwyn Leeks, the psychiatrist accused of mistreating young patients at Lake Alice Hospital in Manawatu in the 1970s, has handed in his medical licence in Australia, on the eve of a disciplinary hearing against him.


2006-0721 - NZ Herald - Lake Alice doctor pre-empts tribunal
Dr Selwyn Leeks, the psychiatrist accused of mistreating young patients at Lake Alice Hospital in the 1970s, has effectively handed in his medical licence, on the eve of a potentially damning disciplinary hearing. The elderly doctor, who had been practising in Melbourne, was to go before a disciplinary panel, accused of unprofessional conduct.


2006-0708 - Waikato Times - Return to Tokanui
by Lester Thorley - Tokanui Hospital has not been caught up in historical complaints levelled at some of the others. In total, more than 300 former patients, from psychiatric hospitals from Auckland to Otago, have alleged abuse. The Government has paid out $10.7 million to 183 people, but has refused to hold an inquiry. It apologised and paid out $6.5 million in compensation in 2001 to 95 former Lake Alice patients over allegations of ill-treatment and sexual abuse by staff and other patients. Complaints are still being investigated at Lake Alice and Porirua.


2006-0706 - Dominion Post - Former patients fight court ruling
More than 150 former mental hospital patients suing for alleged abuse and mistreatment are fighting a court ruling that severely reduces the scope of their claims. The claims, each of up to $500,000 for what happened in the 1960s and 1970s, were cut back to allegations of sex abuse, and mistreatment of informal patients before April 1972.


2006-0607 - Radio NZ - Police review file on former Lake Alice doctor
The police are reviewing their file on a former head doctor at Lake Alice psychiatric hospital near Wanganui, following a fresh complaint of abuse. Last year the police closed their investigation into Dr Selwyn Leeks over complaints of abuse by former patients at the child and adolescent unit he headed between 1972 and 1977. The adolescent unit closed in 1978.



2006-0606 - One News - Lake Alice site for sale
Former Mental Health Unit Lake Alice has been put up for sale by the Whanganui District Health Board. .........The former psychiatric hospital has a checkered history, after allegations by former patients that they were abused by a psychiatrist in the 1970s.


2006-0605 - Dominion Post - Mental hospital staff may face charges
by Hank Schouten - The Crown Law Office is deciding whether former Porirua Hospital staff should be prosecuted over allegations of child abuse. Former patients at the now-closed mental hospital have battled for years for compensation. About 120 former patients say they were abused, beaten, raped or given electric shock treatment as punishment while kept in the hospital during the 1960s and 1970s.


2006-0604 - One News - Psychiatric hospital investigated
Police have been called in to investigate the claims of 300 former patients who say they were mentally, physically and sexually abused at Porirua Psychiatric Hospital almost 40 years ago. The group has already begun a class action suit against the government, seeking an inquiry and compensation for the trauma they suffered as children of the state while at the country's largest psychiatric institution at the time


2006-0526 - Manawatu Standard - Former patient not interested
by Anna Wallis - Mr McMahon was at Lake Alice from age 13 to 16. He says he was raped and tortured at the hospital, and injected with the painful drug paraldehyde and given electroconvulsive shock treatment without anaesthetic


2006-0526 - Manawatu Standard - Ex-Lake Alice boss in Oz sex inquiry
by Anna Wallis - Lake Alice's former head psychiatrist, who's facing charges in Australia on the use of electric-shock treatment and pain-inducing injections on children at the hospital, has also been accused of sexual misconduct by a Melbourne patient. Selwyn Leeks, who was in charge of Lake Alice's child and adolescent unit between 1972 and 1977, is being investigated by the Victorian Medical Practioners' Board over what happened in New Zealand.


2006-0518 - Manawatu Standard - Lake Alice complex up for sale
by Anna Wallis - The former Lake Alice "house of horrors" psychiatric hospital is up for sale - including a water tower and secure prison unit.


2006-0310 - NZ Lawyer - Reliable Evidence and Due Process Revisited   
by Lynley Hood - Nonetheless, Mr Cameron’s comment comes as no surprise. Anyone who questions the reliability of any evidence in any child abuse case is bound to be accused, sooner or later, of “denying the reality of child abuse”. Interestingly, those who question the reliability of the evidence in murder cases are never accused of “denying the reality of murder”.   Of course murder happens. Of course child abuse happens. So why are those who raise questions about child abuse investigations being attacked in this way? Is the evidence in some cases too fragile to withstand close scrutiny? Is accusing one’s questioner of being “in denial” an attempt to shut down the debate?
            Related articles:
            NZ Lawyer October 25 2005; Reliable evidence and due process
            NZ Lawyer January 27 2006; Reliable research and due thought?



2006-0127 - NZ Lawyer - Reliable research and due thought?      
by Grant Cameron - Lynley Hood has done herself a disservice with her recent article entitled “Reliable evidence and due process” (NZ Lawyer issue 28, 28 October 2005). Her article demonstrated a serious misunderstanding of what the determination process in the Lake Alice case was all about and why, more generally, “state and church” institutions might choose to embark on alternative dispute resolution processes. However, much worse is her implication that Sir Rodney Gallen, one of the country’s most respected jurists, erred in the conclusions he expressed in his 2001 report to the Solicitor-General
            Related articles:
            NZ Lawyer October 25 2005; Reliable evidence and due process
            NZ Lawyer March 10 2006; Reliable evidence and due process revisited


2007-0719 - Radio NZ - Former psychiatric patients granted leave to appeal over 1960s abuse


2007-0719 - Newswire - Former Psychiatric Patients May Appeal


2007-0713 - National Business Review - Mistreatment of Lake Alice patients continues


2007-0707 - Dominion Post - Forum for Reconciliation


2007-0706 - Waikato Times - Call for change


2007-0702 - Dominion Post - Patients step up pleas for government payout


2007-0630 - Timaru Herald - Mental health patients to sue Govt


2007-0630 - The Press - Former patients to sue


2007-0630 - Manawatu Standard - Record of abuse is 'words'


2007-0629 - Timaru Herald - Damning report on mental health care


2007-0629 - Three News - Advocate calls for compensation for psychiatric patients


2007-0629 - The Press - Psychiatric-care report


2007-0629 - Stuff - Compo for psychiatric patients 'a difficult issue'


2007-0629 - Southland Times - Damning report on abuse in institutions


2007-0629 - Radio NZ - More scrutiny of Mental Health sector needed - foundation


2007-0629 - Radio NZ - More counselling to be offered to former mental patients


2007-0629 - One News - Abuse won't be forgotten


2007-0629 - NZ Herald - Patients tell of neglect


2007-0629 - Newstalk ZB - Compo would be demeaning for some - Cullen


2007-0629 - Nelson Mail - Ngawhatu part of damning report


2007-0629 - National Party - Lake Alice - Do the right thing


2007-0629 - Dominion Post - 'Zombie' patients tell of cruelty


2007-0629 - Dominion Post - Testaments of hidden desperation


2007-0628 - Radio NZ - No Govt apology offered over psychiatric care report


2007-0628 - One News - Psych report reveals harrowing stories


2007-0628 - One News - Damning psychiatric findings


2007-0628 - NZ Government - Report of the Confidential Forum presented


2007-0628 - NZ Government - Former Patients of Psychiatric Hospitals - Q n A


2007-0628 - Newswire - Report into psychiatric institutions released


2007-0628 - Newstalk ZB - Psych patients share horrors


2007-0628 - Green Party - Former patients deserve an apology, compensation


2007-0627 - NZ Government - Links to Report


2007-0601 - Dominion Post - Ex-patient to get day in court, 50 years on


2007-0501 - NZ Herald - Human rights complaint over hospital assault allegations


2007-0430 - Newswire - Complaint Over Treatment Of Mental Health Patients


2007-0421 - Radio NZ - Questions over training for mental health staff


2007-0421 - Newswire - Mental Health Staff Training Questioned


2007-0420 - Radio NZ - Second case of alleged patient assault confirmed


2007-0420 - Radio NZ - Questions over adequacy of training for union staff


2007-0420 - Radio NZ - MOH won't intervene


2007-0420 - Radio NZ - Earlier case of assault at Porirua with police


2007-0420 - One News - Health unit involved in assault scandal


2007-0420 - NZ Police - Police Investigating Alleged Assault At Haumietiketike


2007-0420 - Newswire - Police investigate assault on mental health patient


2007-0420 - Newstalk ZB - Incident investigated at mental health unit


2007-0420 - Dominion Post - Staff sacked after 'assaults' on patients


2007-0419 - Radio NZ - Mental health worker accused of assaulting patient


2007-0419 - Radio NZ - Lawyer concerned about double standards


2007-0419 - Newstalk ZB - Porirua mental health worker suspended